{"headline": {"total_cases": 181344, "relevant_cases": 17458, "legal_entity_cases": 8781, "countries": 303, "articles": 763, "total_eur": 19384392445.52405, "year_min": 1959, "year_max": 2044, "extracted_at": "2026-04-20T17:10:18.262099Z"}, "by_year": [{"year": 1959, "count": 3, "legal_entity": 2}, {"year": 1960, "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1961, "count": 13, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1962, "count": 8, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1963, "count": 3, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1964, "count": 3, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1965, "count": 8, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1966, "count": 3, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1967, "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1968, "count": 26, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1969, "count": 9, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1970, "count": 12, "legal_entity": 2}, {"year": 1971, "count": 18, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1972, "count": 9, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1973, "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0}, {"year": 1974, "count": 45, "legal_entity": 2}, {"year": 1975, "count": 98, "legal_entity": 6}, {"year": 1976, "count": 187, "legal_entity": 12}, {"year": 1977, "count": 152, "legal_entity": 6}, {"year": 1978, "count": 166, "legal_entity": 25}, {"year": 1979, "count": 140, "legal_entity": 7}, {"year": 1980, "count": 136, "legal_entity": 3}, {"year": 1981, "count": 183, "legal_entity": 6}, {"year": 1982, "count": 188, "legal_entity": 2}, {"year": 1983, "count": 254, "legal_entity": 18}, {"year": 1984, "count": 320, "legal_entity": 1}, {"year": 1985, "count": 267, "legal_entity": 8}, {"year": 1986, "count": 366, "legal_entity": 13}, {"year": 1987, "count": 475, "legal_entity": 12}, {"year": 1988, "count": 507, "legal_entity": 19}, {"year": 1989, "count": 492, "legal_entity": 25}, {"year": 1990, "count": 620, "legal_entity": 25}, {"year": 1991, "count": 1077, "legal_entity": 43}, {"year": 1992, "count": 1300, "legal_entity": 58}, {"year": 1993, "count": 1380, "legal_entity": 53}, {"year": 1994, "count": 2075, "legal_entity": 70}, {"year": 1995, "count": 2835, "legal_entity": 133}, {"year": 1996, "count": 2857, "legal_entity": 92}, {"year": 1997, "count": 3944, "legal_entity": 153}, {"year": 1998, "count": 3851, "legal_entity": 144}, {"year": 1999, "count": 3945, "legal_entity": 169}, {"year": 2000, "count": 4064, "legal_entity": 177}, {"year": 2001, "count": 3545, "legal_entity": 166}, {"year": 2002, "count": 3883, "legal_entity": 183}, {"year": 2003, "count": 3491, "legal_entity": 166}, {"year": 2004, "count": 3617, "legal_entity": 200}, {"year": 2005, "count": 4551, "legal_entity": 204}, {"year": 2006, "count": 5445, "legal_entity": 203}, {"year": 2007, "count": 5876, "legal_entity": 364}, {"year": 2008, "count": 6360, "legal_entity": 273}, {"year": 2009, "count": 6358, "legal_entity": 379}, {"year": 2010, "count": 6016, "legal_entity": 277}, {"year": 2011, "count": 5515, "legal_entity": 280}, {"year": 2012, "count": 6095, "legal_entity": 337}, {"year": 2013, "count": 5881, "legal_entity": 285}, {"year": 2014, "count": 5608, "legal_entity": 333}, {"year": 2015, "count": 5194, "legal_entity": 218}, {"year": 2016, "count": 5113, "legal_entity": 238}, {"year": 2017, "count": 4882, "legal_entity": 217}, {"year": 2018, "count": 4924, "legal_entity": 280}, {"year": 2019, "count": 5006, "legal_entity": 255}, {"year": 2020, "count": 3919, "legal_entity": 240}, {"year": 2021, "count": 4777, "legal_entity": 297}, {"year": 2022, "count": 4438, "legal_entity": 231}, {"year": 2023, "count": 4010, "legal_entity": 231}, {"year": 2024, "count": 3386, "legal_entity": 169}, {"year": 2025, "count": 2610, "legal_entity": 179}, {"year": 2026, "count": 254, "legal_entity": 13}, {"year": 2044, "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0}], "by_country": [{"country": "Turkey", "count": 21862, "legal_entity": 717, "violation_rate": 0.2911242603550296}, {"country": "Italy", "count": 20197, "legal_entity": 917, "violation_rate": 0.42505677517032553}, {"country": "Russia", "count": 12888, "legal_entity": 336, "violation_rate": 0.5025798401510808}, {"country": "France", "count": 11056, "legal_entity": 714, "violation_rate": 0.25429892461946074}, {"country": "Romania", "count": 9930, "legal_entity": 468, "violation_rate": 0.33883225208526413}, {"country": "Ukraine", "count": 8463, "legal_entity": 375, "violation_rate": 0.523943506565155}, {"country": "Poland", "count": 7933, "legal_entity": 127, "violation_rate": 0.2927237712467554}, {"country": "United Kingdom", "count": 7220, "legal_entity": 301, "violation_rate": 0.196357972924404}, {"country": "Greece", "count": 6309, "legal_entity": 369, "violation_rate": 0.39155555555555555}, {"country": "Bulgaria", "count": 4927, "legal_entity": 191, "violation_rate": 0.46638453400019236}, {"country": "Germany", "count": 4603, "legal_entity": 229, "violation_rate": 0.17002262443438915}, {"country": "Hungary", "count": 4295, "legal_entity": 317, "violation_rate": 0.3769070178255982}, {"country": "Croatia", "count": 3970, "legal_entity": 138, "violation_rate": 0.31300268096514744}, {"country": "Austria", "count": 3952, "legal_entity": 364, "violation_rate": 0.25753463790887016}, {"country": "Netherlands", "count": 3185, "legal_entity": 194, "violation_rate": 0.18236226016546384}, {"country": "Portugal", "count": 2972, "legal_entity": 242, "violation_rate": 0.3160947317544708}, {"country": "Switzerland", "count": 2827, "legal_entity": 185, "violation_rate": 0.23785699395455492}, {"country": "Belgium", "count": 2803, "legal_entity": 155, "violation_rate": 0.2905838041431262}, {"country": "Serbia", "count": 2427, "legal_entity": 110, "violation_rate": 0.25766871165644173}, {"country": "Czech Republic", "count": 2330, "legal_entity": 187, "violation_rate": 0.20989399293286218}, {"country": "Spain", "count": 2282, "legal_entity": 178, "violation_rate": 0.21848536172271957}, {"country": "Sweden", "count": 2182, "legal_entity": 130, "violation_rate": 0.12453814388176483}, {"country": "Moldova", "count": 2126, "legal_entity": 323, "violation_rate": 0.44282029234737746}, {"country": "Slovakia", "count": 2095, "legal_entity": 175, "violation_rate": 0.28706896551724137}, {"country": "Azerbaijan", "count": 2059, "legal_entity": 48, "violation_rate": 0.38312213534645456}, {"country": "Slovenia", "count": 1946, "legal_entity": 100, "violation_rate": 0.41265295495964593}, {"country": "Lithuania", "count": 1813, "legal_entity": 64, "violation_rate": 0.3339011925042589}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova", "count": 1528, "legal_entity": 180, "violation_rate": 0.3259721555448872}, {"country": "Finland", "count": 1480, "legal_entity": 68, "violation_rate": 0.21426168853010427}, {"country": "Georgia", "count": 1456, "legal_entity": 61, "violation_rate": 0.2833150784958014}, {"country": "Armenia", "count": 1408, "legal_entity": 112, "violation_rate": 0.5084602368866328}, {"country": "Latvia", "count": 1353, "legal_entity": 43, "violation_rate": 0.2841621395737568}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina", "count": 862, "legal_entity": 50, "violation_rate": 0.40899795501022496}, {"country": "Malta", "count": 824, "legal_entity": 44, "violation_rate": 0.46501706484641636}, {"country": "Albania", "count": 817, "legal_entity": 49, "violation_rate": 0.45034116755117515}, {"country": "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 816, "legal_entity": 34, "violation_rate": 0.19027661357921208}, {"country": "Denmark", "count": 777, "legal_entity": 27, "violation_rate": 0.12973883740522324}, {"country": "Norway", "count": 770, "legal_entity": 63, "violation_rate": 0.28334866605335784}, {"country": "Türkiye", "count": 767, "legal_entity": 27, "violation_rate": 0.413946587537092}, {"country": "Estonia", "count": 707, "legal_entity": 59, "violation_rate": 0.2271186440677966}, {"country": "North Macedonia", "count": 702, "legal_entity": 59, "violation_rate": 0.4191829484902309}, {"country": "Cyprus", "count": 694, "legal_entity": 34, "violation_rate": 0.2892329345531316}, {"country": "Montenegro", "count": 518, "legal_entity": 19, "violation_rate": 0.4822546972860125}, {"country": "Ireland", "count": 501, "legal_entity": 52, "violation_rate": 0.20852713178294574}, {"country": "Iceland", "count": 485, "legal_entity": 18, "violation_rate": 0.3237518910741301}, {"country": "Luxembourg", "count": 381, "legal_entity": 39, "violation_rate": 0.33279483037156704}, {"country": "San Marino", "count": 232, "legal_entity": 10, "violation_rate": 0.273972602739726}, {"country": "The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 225, "legal_entity": 4, "violation_rate": 0.45708582834331335}, {"country": "Slovak Republic", "count": 192, "legal_entity": 10, "violation_rate": 0.3744493392070485}, {"country": "Russian Federation", "count": 159, "legal_entity": 4, "violation_rate": 0.9493087557603687}, {"country": "Liechtenstein", "count": 86, "legal_entity": 2, "violation_rate": 0.2781456953642384}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova and Russia", "count": 85, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6210526315789474}, {"country": "The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 74, "legal_entity": 2, "violation_rate": 0.5488721804511278}, {"country": "Moldova and Russia", "count": 71, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.4841628959276018}, {"country": "Andorra", "count": 68, "legal_entity": 10, "violation_rate": 0.23015873015873015}, {"country": "Monaco", "count": 61, "legal_entity": 13, "violation_rate": 0.1746031746031746}, {"country": "Federal Republic of Germany", "count": 56, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.013793103448275862}, {"country": "Ukraine and Russia", "count": 37, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.08064516129032258}, {"country": "Republic of Macedonia", "count": 37, "legal_entity": 4, "violation_rate": 0.27722772277227725}, {"country": "Belgium and Greece", "count": 32, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5432098765432098}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 32, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6626506024096386}, {"country": "Russia and Ukraine", "count": 30, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Cyprus and Russia", "count": 29, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6287878787878788}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova and Russian Federation", "count": 28, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6693548387096774}, {"country": "ARMENIA", "count": 28, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.5053763440860215}, {"country": "Netherlands and Greece", "count": 27, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Republic of Macedonia", "count": 25, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.4444444444444444}, {"country": "Netherlands and Italy", "count": 23, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Republic of Moldova", "count": 23, "legal_entity": 3, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus and Turkey", "count": 20, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.42857142857142855}, {"country": "RUSSIA", "count": 17, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Georgia and Russia", "count": 15, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.4177215189873418}, {"country": "ROMANIA", "count": 13, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5666666666666667}, {"country": "Italy and Bulgaria", "count": 11, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.3125}, {"country": "the Netherlands", "count": 10, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5714285714285714}, {"country": "AZERBAIJAN", "count": 10, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.43243243243243246}, {"country": "Azerbaijan and Hungary", "count": 9, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6363636363636364}, {"country": "France and Spain", "count": 9, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Italy and Greece", "count": 9, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.7241379310344828}, {"country": "Italy and Germany", "count": 7, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, United Kingdom", "count": 7, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Switzerland and Italy", "count": 7, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Albania and Italy", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Italy and Belgium", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Netherlands", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6}, {"country": "France and Belgium", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.38461538461538464}, {"country": "Romania and Hungary", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.75}, {"country": "Macedonia", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6}, {"country": "the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 6, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.2}, {"country": "UKRAINE", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6428571428571429}, {"country": "Czechoslovakia", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Azerbaijan and Turkey", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.68}, {"country": "MOLDOVA", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.25}, {"country": "Romania and France", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Ireland", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Romania and Bulgaria", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "The United Kingdom", "count": 5, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Turkey and Greece", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Austria and Italy", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Azerbaijan and Georgia", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.4666666666666667}, {"country": "Finland and Sweden", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France and Greece", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova, Russia, Ukraine", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.2222222222222222}, {"country": "France, Germany, Norway", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Germany, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Spain, Finland, France, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal, United Kingdom, Sweden", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, Serbia", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Romania and Russia", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "CROATIA", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.4}, {"country": "Lithuania and Sweden", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.4444444444444444}, {"country": "the Republic of Moldova", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Greece and Germany", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Italy and France", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.25}, {"country": "Hungary and Ireland", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "the Republic of Moldova and Russia", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "ESTONIA", "count": 4, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Belgium and France", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Romania and Austria", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France and Germany", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Turkey and Switzerland", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.2857142857142857}, {"country": "Italy and the Netherlands", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Portugal and 32 other states", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Serbia and Montenegro", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Poland and Greece", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.375}, {"country": "the United Kingdom", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Poland and Germany", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.125}, {"country": "Portugal and 32 other States", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Romania and Turkey", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Germany and Greece", "count": 3, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.46153846153846156}, {"country": "Denmark and Greece", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Turkey and Denmark", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Republic of North Macedonia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Germany and the United Kingdom", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "THE NETHERLANDS", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus, Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Sweden", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Sweden", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Portugal and 32 other Signatory States to the 2015 Paris Agreement", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Czech Republic and Germany", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Moldova and Russian Federation", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Slovenia, Serbia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.8}, {"country": "European Communities and Member States (Belgium, Denmark, France, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Federal Republic of Germany, Netherlands, United Kingdom)", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 2, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "46 member States of the Council of Europe", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Albania and Greece", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Montenegro and Serbia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Italy and Albania", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Albania", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Member States of the European Union", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Federal Republic of Germany and the Netherlands", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Moldova and the Russian Federation", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Greece and the United Kingdom", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Lithuania and Russia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "the Republic of Moldova and the Russian Federation", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.7777777777777778}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova and Romania", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece, Ukraine", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5}, {"country": "15 States of the European Union", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 2, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium and Serbia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Romania and Germany", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Romania and the United Kingdom", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.25}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova, Russian Federation, Ukraine", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.16666666666666666}, {"country": "Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and the United Kingdom", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 2, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and the Netherlands", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Slovakia and Ukraine", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5}, {"country": "Belgium and Italy", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and North Macedonia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Slovakia", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5}, {"country": "46 Member States of the Council of Europe", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Ireland and the United Kingdom", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Armenia and Moldova", "count": 2, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.2222222222222222}, {"country": "Italy and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, France, and 32 other member states", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, France, and 32 other member states of the Council of Europe", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "San Marino and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Ireland, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "46 Council of Europe Member States", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Austria", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Poland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "15 Member States of the European Union", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Serbia and North Macedonia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Norway, Sweden, Finland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, France, and 32 other Council of Europe member states", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Armenia and Russia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Poland and Sweden", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Slovenia and Austria", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus and Latvia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Poland and Ukraine", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Türkiye", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "unknown", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Algeria", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Serbia and Slovenia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "TURKEY", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands and Czech Republic", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Multiple states (see case_name)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, and \"former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia\"", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "All 47 member states of the Council of Europe", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, Norway, Germany", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Ukraine and Poland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands and Georgia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Moldova and Ukraine", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus, Greece, Turkey, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bulgaria and Turkey", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Portugal and Luxembourg", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Italy and Netherlands", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Slovakia and Germany", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia-Herzegovina", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Greece", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Romania and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Spain and Andorra", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus and Russian Federation", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Turkey, Ukraine and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, Norway", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Austria and Hungary", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Ukraine and Slovakia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "European Communities and their Member States", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bulgaria, Ukraine, Russia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Republic of Moldova and the Russian Federation", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Poland and Romania", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Serbia and Slovenia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Romania", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands and Ukraine", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Turkey, Austria, Germany", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus, Turkey, United Nations", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Germany, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Spain, Finland, France, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, the United Kingdom, Sweden", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium and France (and 32 other High Contracting Parties)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "15 states of European Union", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bulgaria and Sweden", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Norway and Greece", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, Finland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "Multiple states (15 respondent states)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "47 Member States of the Council of Europe", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Spain and France", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bulgaria and Russia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Albania, Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "THE FORMER YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "LATVIA", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Montenegro, Serbia, Bosnia and Herzegovina", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Federal Republic of Germany", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands and United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Country", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Ukraine and the Czech Republic", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Cyprus, Greece, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Germany and Belgium", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "15 EU Member States", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "the Netherlands and Greece", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Andorra, France, Spain", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Greece and Switzerland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Czech Republic and Slovakia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Austria", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France and Turkey", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "SWEDEN", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, Belgium and 32 other Council of Europe member states", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Multiple states (Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Turkey, Ukraine, United Kingdom)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Russia and Georgia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Contracting States to the European Patent Convention", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Armenia and Azerbaijan", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, Macedonia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.6666666666666666}, {"country": "France and Belgium (and 32 other member states)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and 26 other EU Member States", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, \"the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia\", Serbia and Slovenia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Azerbaijan and Ukraine", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Slovenia, \"the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia\"", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "BELGIUM", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Belgium and France (plus 32 other Council of Europe member states)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium and Romania", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands and Malta", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Multiple states (21 respondent states listed in case name)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Portugal and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Multiple respondent states (see case_name)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium and France (among others)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Germany", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Netherlands and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Netherlands, Turkey", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.5}, {"country": "France, Cyprus, Switzerland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France and Switzerland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Multiple States", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "France, the Federal Republic of Germany and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Germany and France", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Georgia and Azerbaijan", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 1, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Belgium, Denmark, Germany, France, Greece, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, the Czech Republic, Turkey, Hungary and the United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Ireland and United Kingdom", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Hungary and Italy", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "34 State members of the Council of Europe (including Belgium and France)", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Republic of Moldova and Russia", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and Spain", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Lithuania and Romania", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 1.0}, {"country": "Italy and Poland", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "United Kingdom and 26 other member States of the European Union", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "Armenia and Republic of Moldova", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.25}, {"country": "34 member States of the Council of Europe", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}, {"country": "The Republic of Moldova and the Russian Federation", "count": 1, "legal_entity": 0, "violation_rate": 0.0}], "by_applicant_type": [{"type": "natural_person", "count": 163883}, {"type": "legal_entity", "count": 8781}, {"type": "mixed", "count": 4963}, {"type": "null", "count": 106}], "by_category": [{"category": "C_irrelevant", "count": 160418}, {"category": "A_legal_entity_applicant", "count": 9510}, {"category": "D_mixed", "count": 4121}, {"category": "B_individual_with_corporate_rights", "count": 3823}], "by_article_outcome": [{"article": "6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 33441}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 22014}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 14138}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12180}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 11460}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10748}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10192}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 9289}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9268}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8836}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8797}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8479}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6133}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4881}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4798}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4197}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3856}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3848}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3646}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3563}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3346}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3294}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3237}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3131}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3054}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2899}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2827}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2734}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2666}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2584}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2527}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2471}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2434}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2255}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2188}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2134}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2086}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2017}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1950}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1903}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1902}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1797}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1795}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1691}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1623}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1602}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1579}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1536}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1529}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1528}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1245}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1242}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1232}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1174}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1103}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1102}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1003}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 972}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 971}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 954}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 951}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 931}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 852}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 809}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 744}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "violation", "count": 735}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 691}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 675}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 671}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "violation", "count": 671}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 662}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 648}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 638}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 595}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 592}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 591}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 589}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 582}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 553}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 534}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 533}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 532}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 530}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 521}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 520}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 515}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 498}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 497}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 496}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 491}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 485}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 471}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 471}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 467}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 455}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 449}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 446}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 444}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 404}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 397}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 377}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 374}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 367}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 364}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 363}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 362}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 355}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 352}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 348}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 344}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 344}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 331}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 320}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 319}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 305}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 303}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 295}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 292}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 277}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "violation", "count": 273}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 265}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 262}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 259}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 255}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 250}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 248}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 246}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 243}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 240}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 239}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 221}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 221}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 218}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 217}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 217}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 216}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 211}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 210}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 207}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 207}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "violation", "count": 202}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "violation", "count": 199}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 187}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 186}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 185}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "violation", "count": 178}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 176}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 173}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 171}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 166}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 163}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 161}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 152}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 151}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 149}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 149}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 147}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 146}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 145}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "violation", "count": 145}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 143}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 141}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 141}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 139}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 137}, {"article": "37", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 135}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 133}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 128}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 127}, {"article": "26", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 124}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 123}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 122}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 119}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 119}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 117}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 116}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 115}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "violation", "count": 115}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "violation", "count": 115}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 113}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 112}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 108}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 108}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 107}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 106}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 104}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 104}, {"article": "4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 102}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 101}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 101}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 100}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 99}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 98}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 98}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 97}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 97}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 93}, {"article": "P4-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 92}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 92}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 92}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 92}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 86}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 86}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 86}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 85}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 85}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 81}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 80}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 80}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 79}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 77}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 77}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 77}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 76}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 76}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 76}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 75}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 75}, {"article": "37-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 75}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 74}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 73}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 72}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 71}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "violation", "count": 70}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 70}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 69}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 69}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 67}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 67}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 65}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 63}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 62}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 62}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 60}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 60}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 60}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 58}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 57}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 56}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 54}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 54}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 54}, {"article": "various", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 54}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 53}, {"article": "37-1-a", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 52}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 52}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 52}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 52}, {"article": "P6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 52}, {"article": "11-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 50}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 50}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 50}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 49}, {"article": "4-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 48}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 47}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 47}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 47}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 47}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 46}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 46}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 46}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 44}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 44}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 44}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 43}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 43}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 43}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 43}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 42}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 42}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 42}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 42}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "violation", "count": 42}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 40}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 40}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 40}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 39}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 39}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 38}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 38}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 38}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 38}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 38}, {"article": "35-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 38}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 38}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 37}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 37}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 37}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 37}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 37}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 36}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 36}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 36}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 36}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 36}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 36}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 35}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 35}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 35}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 35}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 35}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 34}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 34}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 34}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 34}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 33}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 33}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 33}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 33}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 32}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 32}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 32}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 32}, {"article": "null", "outcome": "null", "count": 31}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 30}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 30}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 30}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 30}, {"article": "60", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 30}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 29}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 29}, {"article": "P1-1+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 29}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 29}, {"article": "6-3c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 28}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 28}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 28}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 28}, {"article": "39", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 28}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 28}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 28}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 28}, {"article": "35-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 28}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 28}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 27}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 27}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 27}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 27}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 26}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 26}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 26}, {"article": "26", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 26}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 26}, {"article": "6-3(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 25}, {"article": "46-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 25}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 25}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 25}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 24}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 24}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 24}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 24}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 23}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 23}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 23}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 23}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 22}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 22}, {"article": "P4-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 22}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 22}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 22}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 22}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 21}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 21}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 21}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 21}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 20}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 20}, {"article": "37-1-c", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 20}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 20}, {"article": "P4-2-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 20}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 19}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 19}, {"article": "8+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 19}, {"article": "4-P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 19}, {"article": "7-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 19}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 19}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 19}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 19}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 19}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 19}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 19}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 18}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "P7-2-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 18}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 18}, {"article": "14+6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "14+6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 18}, {"article": "6-1+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 17}, {"article": "5 § 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 17}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 17}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 17}, {"article": "P4-3-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 17}, {"article": "26", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 17}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 17}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 17}, {"article": "14+10", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 17}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 16}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 16}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 16}, {"article": "P6-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 16}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 16}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 15}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 15}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "6-3d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 15}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "4-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 15}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 15}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 15}, {"article": "5§4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 15}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 15}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 15}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 15}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 15}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 14}, {"article": "6-3(d)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 14}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 14}, {"article": "P1-1+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 14}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 14}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 14}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 13}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 13}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 13}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 13}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 13}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 13}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 13}, {"article": "5 § 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 13}, {"article": "6-3(b)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 12}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 12}, {"article": "27-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "P12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 12}, {"article": "P7-4-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 12}, {"article": "4-P4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 12}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 12}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "P1-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 12}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 12}, {"article": "P4-14", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 12}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 12}, {"article": "14+10", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 12}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 11}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 11}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 11}, {"article": "5.4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 11}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 11}, {"article": "6-3(a)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 11}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 11}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 11}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 11}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 11}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 11}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 11}, {"article": "46-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 11}, {"article": "P7-4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 11}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 11}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 11}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 10}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "6-3b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "friendly_settlement", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 10}, {"article": "35-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "13+P4-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "5.1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 10}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 10}, {"article": "16", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 10}, {"article": "14+9", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "14+9", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "null", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 10}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 10}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "5§1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "5/4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 10}, {"article": "6-3(c)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 10}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 10}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 9}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 9}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 9}, {"article": "Article 3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 9}, {"article": "5/3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "6-1+6-3-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "Article 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "Article 2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "14+9", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 9}, {"article": "10-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 9}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 9}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 9}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 9}, {"article": "3 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 9}, {"article": "6/1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 9}, {"article": "Article 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "6.1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 9}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 9}, {"article": "6-3(d)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "14+5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "Article 1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "4-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 8}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "27-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "5.1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "5.3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 8}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 8}, {"article": "4-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 8}, {"article": "14+9", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 8}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "14+6", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 8}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 8}, {"article": "P4-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 8}, {"article": "5/1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "4 P4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 8}, {"article": "35-3-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 8}, {"article": "P1-7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 8}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 7}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 7}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 7}, {"article": "Article 4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 7}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 7}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 7}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 7}, {"article": "27", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "5/3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 7}, {"article": "38-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 7}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 7}, {"article": "6-3(b)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "P2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "13+P1-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 7}, {"article": "13+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 7}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 7}, {"article": "P6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "13+3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "3+13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "6-3(b)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "14+6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "35-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 7}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 7}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "37-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 6}, {"article": "19", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "13+3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "5 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 6}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 6}, {"article": "14+6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 6}, {"article": "14+5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "P4-2-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 6}, {"article": "6/1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6}, {"article": "4-P4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 6}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 6}, {"article": "13+3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "2-P4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "4-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "14+12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 6}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 6}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 6}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 6}, {"article": "33", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "3-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 6}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 6}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-3-g", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 6}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-3c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "P6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "3+13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "14+4-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 6}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "1 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "4P4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 6}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 6}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "4-3-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "Article 35", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 5}, {"article": "4 Protocol 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 5}, {"article": "38-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "13+P4-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "5§3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 5}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 5}, {"article": "Article 5-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 5}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 5}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+11", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-3d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-3(c)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "P4-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 5}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 5}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "38-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "13+8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 5}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 5}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 5}, {"article": "P1-6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "38-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 5}, {"article": "P7-4-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+10", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 5}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 5}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-1+6-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 5}, {"article": "P2-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-1+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "4 of Protocol 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "27-1-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 5}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 5}, {"article": "46-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "P4-3-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "5/5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "63", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 5}, {"article": "23", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 5}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 5}, {"article": "8-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "4-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 5}, {"article": "14+4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 4}, {"article": "14+12", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "applicable", "count": 4}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 4}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 4}, {"article": "13+P1-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "3+14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "applicable", "count": 4}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 4}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 4}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 4}, {"article": "P12-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 4}, {"article": "18+5-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "14+3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 4}, {"article": "6.1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-1+13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "5.4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P4-7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P12", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "5§5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "Article 3 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "3 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 4}, {"article": "P6-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 4}, {"article": "P1-1+13", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "14+5-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P4-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 4}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 4}, {"article": "3+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "22", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "35-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 4}, {"article": "P6", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 4}, {"article": "9-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "failure to comply with obligations", "count": 4}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 4}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "1-P12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "14+4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 4}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 4}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "P7-2-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "46-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "4 Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 4}, {"article": "15-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P2-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "15-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "pilot_judgment", "count": 4}, {"article": "P2-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-3-g", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "46-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "5-1c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "46-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "P1-1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 4}, {"article": "4 Protocol 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "1 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 4}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 4}, {"article": "P2-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "failure to comply", "count": 4}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 4}, {"article": "P4-2-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 4}, {"article": "18+P4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 4}, {"article": "P1-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 3}, {"article": "P3-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 3}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 3}, {"article": "17+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "18+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "4-7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "48", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "6(1)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "2-2", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "null", "count": 3}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "null", "count": 3}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "null", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "null", "count": 3}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1+6-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-3(c)", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "25.1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 3}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "no violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "5/1 c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "8+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "10+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "former 25", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "Article 18", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-1-a", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "17+11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "4-2+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1, 6-2, 6-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 3}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "5§3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "11-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "partially_admissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 3}, {"article": "5 § 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 3}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 3}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 3}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not necessary to consider", "count": 3}, {"article": "30", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "Article 13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "partially admissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "7-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 3}, {"article": "3 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "preliminary objection dismissed", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 3}, {"article": "3-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "37/1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "37", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "11+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "Preamble", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "11-14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "37-1-b", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "13 combined with 3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "P7-4-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "Article 5-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 3}, {"article": "18+5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "8+13", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "13-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "13-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "28-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "5(3)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+5-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 3}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "null", "count": 3}, {"article": "4-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "4P4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 3}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 3}, {"article": "27-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 3}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "9-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "13+P1-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially inadmissible, partially admissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-3-g", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "10-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "4-7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P1-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "pending", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-3a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "6-3(e)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "4-3-d", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+P4-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "9+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "13+8", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 3}, {"article": "P7-4-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 3}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P4-3-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "33", "outcome": "violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+5-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "14+9-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 3}, {"article": "2-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P4-7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 3}, {"article": "P6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "victim status accepted", "count": 2}, {"article": "P12-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "37", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 § 1 (f)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "64", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-3+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5.5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "27", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "1 of Protocol 6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P3-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6§1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "6/1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 2}, {"article": "28", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "25.1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+P1-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+9", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 5", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 37", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-5", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "18+5-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_consider", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 10", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-2 combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 2}, {"article": "18-5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "36", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "partially inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "no_action", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3(d)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3(d)", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "1 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+P4-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "7-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13 combined with 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "19", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "partially_admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "3-P1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+6", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "38 § 1 (a)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "pilot judgment", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "14 combined with 6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5/4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 2}, {"article": "P13-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P13-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "incompatible ratione materiae", "count": 2}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "unnecessary to decide", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 8", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "10-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "4", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-3-d", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "33", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "2-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "4P2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 § 5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+14+8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "38 § 1(a)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 2}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "9-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "37-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "27-1-b", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "not_addressed", "count": 2}, {"article": "38-1", "outcome": "not_addressed", "count": 2}, {"article": "5.3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "incompatible_ratione_materiae", "count": 2}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "advisory_opinion", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 P4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "7-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "preliminary objection dismissed", "count": 2}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "5/3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1+6-3-b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "6/2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 § 4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 Protocol 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 Protokołu nr 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "non-lieu à examen", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "non-lieu à examen", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-1c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+P4-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "9-14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 5-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3-e", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "3-P4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "3-P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "5§1(f)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 2}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "18+10", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "victim status upheld", "count": 2}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "null", "count": 2}, {"article": "54", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "3 Protocol 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "9+14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "Article 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "null", "count": 2}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+11", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 2}, {"article": "27-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 P1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "advisory_opinion", "count": 2}, {"article": "19", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "5.3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "incompatible", "count": 2}, {"article": "3-13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-P7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3(a)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 Protocol 7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 2}, {"article": "39", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "1 and 2 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "24", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-3(g)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not necessary to examine complaint", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "pending", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "pending", "count": 2}, {"article": "3+13", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no need to examine", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 4. Prot.", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "38(1)(a)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "ne bis in idem", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-1a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 § 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_consider", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-P4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "13+4-P4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "45-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "5 § 1 lit. b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "11-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "5-1-a+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+4-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "3-P1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 6-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "31", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 2}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 2}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-3-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1+14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "8+13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 2}, {"article": "P1-1-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partly inadmissible, partly admissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 Prot. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "6 § 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 2}, {"article": "4-P7-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+5-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "3 of Protocol 1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 2}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 2}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "failure to comply with Article 38", "count": 2}, {"article": "2 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "14+8-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 2}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "failure to comply with its obligations", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-2-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "pas lieu d'examiner", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "failure to fulfil obligations", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3+8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-c", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "partially inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "not_addressed", "count": 1}, {"article": "18 in conjunction with 5-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-e", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "P12", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "partly inadmissible, partly adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3.d", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 4. ZPEMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 EMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 (medical)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 (medical)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1, 6-3-c", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "47", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 read in conjunction with 13", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "30-1-a", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3+14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "preliminary objection dismissed", "count": 1}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "request dismissed", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 with 14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "11 with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "46-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 of Protocol 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-2-c", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "35", "outcome": "partly_inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 1. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "21", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "22", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "47", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.3.c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.3.b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "60", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially_inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "execution_measures", "count": 1}, {"article": "5§1(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 Protocol 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 Protocol 12", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_consider", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 35", "outcome": "preliminary objection dismissed", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P7", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "49", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3(b)", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 du Protocole n° 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 du Protocole n° 12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+6-1+6-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "various", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+6-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-3+8+10", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1, 6-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P12-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "examination not necessary", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "13-8", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Friendly settlement", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 of Protocol 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 35-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-6", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4+6-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-e+5-4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-1-b", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-1-c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "various", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combined with 2 and 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 in conjunction with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "withdrawn", "count": 1}, {"article": "35 § 1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "not_considered", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-c-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-13", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d+6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-c combined with 18", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-f combined with 18", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "null", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-13", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 c", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P4-2-1+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 read in conjunction with 6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "7-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "15-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 with 6-3-b and 6-3-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 with 2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 interpreted with 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 du Protocole n° 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in relation to 6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8 in relation to 6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1 c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "5§1 c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5 § 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5 § 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 34", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5 § 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3+6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-13", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4P7-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "not necessary to consider", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-3-a", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-12-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "partially admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-1", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "under examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "manquement à se conformer à l'article 38", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "not necessary to decide issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not necessary to decide issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+10", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 combined with 14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "6 § 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "failure to comply", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+6-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 (inadequate conditions of detention during transport)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no need to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "no need to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "no need to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no need to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 1}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "7 combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 6", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 4 and 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "33", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "46-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "46-2", "outcome": "pilot-judgment procedure closed", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 7. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-4-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "Prot. 1 Art. 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "28-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "article 2 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+9", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5.2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.3.a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.3.d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-3-a", "outcome": "preliminary objection dismissed", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "incompatible_ratione_materiae", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "17+P1-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "18+P1-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-1+4-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P4-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "30", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "satisfaction_granted", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+14+8", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "44", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 (c)", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 of Protocol No. 12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1 (c)", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "Art 1 12. ZPEMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combined with 3 and 5 § 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "35.1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "35.3 a", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_examination_called_for", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no_examination_called_for", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+14", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "joined to merits", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "13-8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "18 in conjunction with 5-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "38 § 1 a)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 4. ZPEMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "UN-Kinderrechtskonvention 3-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-3(b)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 6-3-d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "38(1)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-в", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P3-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "53", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-1+11", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "incompatible ratione temporis", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "incompatible ratione temporis", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 (c)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with Article 3 of the Convention and Article 4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "37-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5.5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 13 and 17", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6+8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-a-e", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 f)", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "non-lieu à examen", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "non-lieu à examen", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+9", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "ICCPR-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "P13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+5-3", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-P7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "33", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "21-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-3-b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 du Protocole no 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "38 § 1 a)", "outcome": "manquement", "count": 1}, {"article": "2", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "24", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "partially recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 of the European Convention on the Recognition of the Legal Personality of International Non-Governmental Organisations", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "30-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P4-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-14", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "7-P1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6(2)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6(3)(c)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6(3)(d)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 4. ZPEMRK", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "11-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "18-P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-7-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 from Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-g", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 of Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "applicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "unnecessary to consider", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "unnecessary to consider", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with Article 8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 and 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no need to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "no need to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/3-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+3+9+10+11", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 combined with 8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 combined with P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P12-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "29", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "43", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 5-1 and 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "applicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 8", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1 a)", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "10-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-P4-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 Protokołu nr 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1+14", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 Protocol 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "former Article 25", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Protocol 7 Article 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with 3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "27-1-b", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-6-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "28-1(a)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no separate ruling", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "no separate ruling", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no separate ruling", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no separate ruling", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+P1-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "60", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 13 and 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "9-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 9", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-f", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 1", "outcome": "within the jurisdiction", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "no violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "partially admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "partially admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-13", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "27-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 37", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 37-1-c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "7.1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5.1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5.2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "12-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1 c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "article 4 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "18+5-1-e", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "no_further_action", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+10", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "not_examined_separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "41", "outcome": "award made", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3.d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "39", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-P1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c+6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-e+6-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-b+6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-1-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-3", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "13-2-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "13-5", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3(a)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially_admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 29 Oviedo Convention", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "10+8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+5+6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5+6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-7 Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.3.c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-P4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "unknown", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 1}, {"article": "8 (correspondence)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-13", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 du Protocole n°4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 Protokolu 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "no_violation, violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-4", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "37 § 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 combined with 13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P6-1", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+14", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "21+26", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-procedural", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-procedural", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-2", "outcome": "withdrawn", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "withdrawn", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "withdrawn", "count": 1}, {"article": "8-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "21", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "other unspecified articles", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3(b)", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with Article 5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 combined with Article 3 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 1 of Protocol No. 12", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "52", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "54", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "4. gr. 7. viðauka", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 (fairness)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "admissibility_decision_pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "article 2 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-P7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "18+5-3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combiné avec l'article 4 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "P12-1", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 35-3", "outcome": "incompatible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 du Protocole n°1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P12", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3b", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 4. ZPEMRK", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-2", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not addressed", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not addressed separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+P1-1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 iVm. Art. 8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "9+14", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "4+P7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combined with 3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+8", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "partially inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "32-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no separate finding", "count": 1}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "no separate finding", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5-1-b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1-c", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4. gr. 7. viðauka", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "7-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "34-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "no separate examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+6-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "4.3.d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "37§1(c)", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+P4-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "null", "count": 1}, {"article": "5(1)(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5(1)(e)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5(5)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combiné avec l’article 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "failure to discharge obligations", "count": 1}, {"article": "4(1) of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "37 § 1 a) and c)", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "51", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "not pursued", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "not pursued", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-3-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+P1-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "35§3(b)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Protocol 4 Article 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P3-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "partly inadmissible, partly adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 § 1 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "no_separate_examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "no_separate_examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-1 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "37 § 1 a)", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 du Protocole n° 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1+P12-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "severed", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "null", "count": 1}, {"article": "4P7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "9+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2 of Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-14", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "incompatible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "partially_admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combiné avec 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3+14", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+14+P1-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "38.1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "50", "outcome": "partial satisfaction", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+4-2+4-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "non bis in idem", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 of Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P9-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-13", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1", "outcome": "non-lieu à statuer", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "non-lieu à statuer", "count": 1}, {"article": "health_right", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+4-3", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "9+14", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-7", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 6-3(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 combined with 6-3(d)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+6-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 (b)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "46-2", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2-4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "no_separate_examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "inferences drawn", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_consider", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_jurisdiction", "count": 1}, {"article": "13-14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "not_examined_further", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "not_necessary_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 in conjunction with 13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-3-1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "38", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "10+11", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-4-2", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-3-a", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "2. gr. samningsviðauka 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 3 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 3 para. 2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 29 of the Oviedo Convention", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2+9-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "not necessary to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 al. 2 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 17", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 in conjunction with 6-3-c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-b", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-2-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 and 3 iVm. Art. 1 6. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "exception préliminaire rejetée", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "not necessary to examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+12", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/3", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+P1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "9+P1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "17", "outcome": "not_examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3c", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3d", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "no breach of the obligation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 6-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6(1)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "not necessary to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not necessary to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not necessary to examine separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "10 in conjunction with 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+8", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5", "outcome": "incompatible_ratione_materiae", "count": 1}, {"article": "15", "outcome": "mixed", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "no_action", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-3", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 taken together with 3", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 Protocol 4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3+14", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-g", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-1+P12-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "admissibility_adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-P4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "16", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1-1-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6.2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+6-3-e", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "not pursued", "count": 1}, {"article": "5§4", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "no_separate_examination", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+P1-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+8-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 1}, {"article": "25", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "Convention generally", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "Protocol No. 7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 7. Prot.", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-P1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "partly_admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 (duration)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1 combined with 13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "adjourned", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6§1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5-1-e", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "37-1-c", "outcome": "not struck out", "count": 1}, {"article": "38 § 1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "partly admissible, partly inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "N/A", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+6-3-c", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6", "outcome": "no jurisdiction", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-2-4-ZPEMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "10-14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "18", "outcome": "not examined separately", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3d", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 3", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 13", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-3", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1, 6-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1-13", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 sbr. 14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Prot. 7 Art. 2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-6", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 4. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 EMRK", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5(1)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "victim status", "count": 1}, {"article": "38-1-a", "outcome": "not_addressed", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 4. Prot.", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+4-P4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "11-9", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-d", "outcome": "incompatible_ratione_materiae", "count": 1}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "P5-7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "38-1a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "incompatible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 c)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "other", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3+14", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6+14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 du Protocole n°1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "9", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "no separate issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-4", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2-2-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "partly inadmissible, partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+4P4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Protocol 6 Article 1", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "former 25", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P3-6", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with 5", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "29", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-2", "outcome": "affaire communiquée", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-a", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "admissibility_deferred", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-8", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-2-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "10 § 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "11 § 1", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+4-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not examined", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 Protocol 7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "10-2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+6-3(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+4-3(d)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+14", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3+14", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 combined with 3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 3 du Protocole n° 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3 b)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3 d)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "P13-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-10", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-11", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3 d", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "38 § 1 (a)", "outcome": "failure to comply", "count": 1}, {"article": "25-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "not examined further", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 1. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with 2", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "no_separate_issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "communicated", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1+13", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "2+P1-6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3+P1-6", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+7-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P4-2", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3(a-c)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "partly admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3", "outcome": "partially_inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 5", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "3 7. Prot. EMRK", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P2-1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/3(c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/2", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/3(a)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6/3(d)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "1 of Protocol No. 1", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+5-1", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "failure to comply with Article 34", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 Prot. 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1+14", "outcome": "inapplicable", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 (c)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "incompatible ratione materiae", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "partially inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 37-1-c", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P7-5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P2-1+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-3", "outcome": "partly inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "pending", "count": 1}, {"article": "6(1)", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "10", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "unnecessary to examine issue", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+6+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "12", "outcome": "irrecevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1+18", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P6-2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-5", "outcome": "manifestly ill-founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "13", "outcome": "non-lieu à statuer", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+8+9", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "11", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "manifestly_ill_founded", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3 b", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3 c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "12+14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1 (other)", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "8+P12-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "7", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-1", "outcome": "no_need_to_examine", "count": 1}, {"article": "5/1c", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-1-1-a", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "P7-3", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "35-1", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "58", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "Article 39", "outcome": "friendly_settlement", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-a-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14 in conjunction with 5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-1-P7", "outcome": "struck_out", "count": 1}, {"article": "article 2 du Protocole n° 4", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "34", "outcome": "unknown", "count": 1}, {"article": "7-4", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "P1-12", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-2", "outcome": "receivable", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+4-3-d", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "46", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-d", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+14+P1-1", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+2", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+7", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3-a and 6-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-3-c combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4 P7", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "29", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1 and 6-3 combined", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "38 § 1 a", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "6-1-3-c", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "2 of Protocol No. 4", "outcome": "inapplicable_to_legal_entity", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "14-9", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "14+P1-1", "outcome": "recevable", "count": 1}, {"article": "8 combined with 14", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-2", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13 in conjunction with 3", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5.5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "4-3-b", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5 § 1 e)", "outcome": "violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "8", "outcome": "not necessary to examine complaint", "count": 1}, {"article": "14", "outcome": "not necessary to examine complaint", "count": 1}, {"article": "3-14", "outcome": "no_violation", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-1-b", "outcome": "admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "5-4", "outcome": "partially inadmissible, partially admissible", "count": 1}, {"article": "13+5", "outcome": "inadmissible", "count": 1}], "soe_cases": [{"doc_id": "001-233792", "case_name": "ABDOVIĆ I DRUGI protiv CRNE GORE", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-127124", "case_name": "MARINKOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-67580", "case_name": "MYKHAYLENKY AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-117498", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-155566", "case_name": "ȘTEFĂNESCU v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-154519", "case_name": "ÖSTERREICHISCHER RUNDFUNK GEGN AUSTURRIKI", "country": "Austria", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-174487", "case_name": "Liseytseva and Maslov v. Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-186411", "case_name": "LIBERT v. FRANCE", "country": "France", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-146892", "case_name": "Tomislav BOGATIROV against Serbia and 19 other applications", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-104265", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-114310", "case_name": "ŠEFĆETA HODŽIĆ AGAINST SERBIA AND 4 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-153756", "case_name": "Natsvlishvili and Togonidze v. Georgia", "country": "Georgia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-125572", "case_name": "Romashov v. Ukraine", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-176974", "case_name": "KRNĐIJA AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-152958", "case_name": "Nikolay Filippovich DEMIDOV against Russia and 3 other applications", "country": "Russia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-145219", "case_name": "RIĐIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-95905", "case_name": "KHACHATRYAN v. ARMENIA", "country": "Armenia", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-78528", "case_name": "YEREMENKO v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-233559", "case_name": "DEDIĆ I DRUGI protiv CRNE GORE", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-203355", "case_name": "Viktor Oleksiyovych Vitryak v. Ukraine", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-182071", "case_name": "NATALYA VLADIMIROVNA TUPITSINA AND LYUDMILA PAVLOVNA BABOSHINA AGAINST RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-172322", "case_name": "MARUNIĆ v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-174881", "case_name": "ZASTAVA IT TURS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-148093", "case_name": "JANKOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-228701", "case_name": "UKRAINE v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-63018", "case_name": "VELHO DA COSTA DE ABREU ROCHA ET TITO DE MORAIS c. PORTUGAL", "country": "Portugal", "year": 2000}, {"doc_id": "001-172378", "case_name": "GAYDAY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-127793", "case_name": "CEBOTARI v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-158770", "case_name": "MEĆAVA v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-77940", "case_name": "NEGRICH v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-200236", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-169554", "case_name": "SOKOLOV AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-231356", "case_name": "ZEJNELOVIĆ AND PAJOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2022}, {"doc_id": "001-142860", "case_name": "ADAMOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-174764", "case_name": "NAK NAFTOGAZ UKRAINY v. THE UNITED KINGDOM", "country": "United Kingdom", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-123474", "case_name": "GROZA AND MARIN v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-152733", "case_name": "STANKO STANOJEVIĆ AGAINST SERBIA AND 5 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-142876", "case_name": "CRNIŠANIN AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-145573", "case_name": "JOVANOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "002-12007", "case_name": "Libert v. France", "country": "France", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-169098", "case_name": "LISEYTSEVA AND MASLOV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-216262", "case_name": "SLOVENIA v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-145480", "case_name": "Radmilo VUKAJLOVIĆ against Serbia and 82 other applications", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-243393", "case_name": "FEODOSIYSKA SUDNOBUDIVNA KOMPANIYA MORE, VAT against Russia and 2 other applications", "country": "Russia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-126381", "case_name": "RADOSAV NEŠIĆ AGAINST SERBIA AND 17 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-118196", "case_name": "BRODSKA LINIJE ISLAMSKE REPUBLIKE IRAN PROTIV TURSKE", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-23812", "case_name": "SLOVENSKÉ TELEKOMUNIKÁCIE, š.p., HEROLD TELE MEDIA, s.r.o. and František EKE against Slovakia", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-200237", "case_name": "RTBF v. Belgium", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-112762", "case_name": "CLIONOV v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-200331", "case_name": "ANDREYEV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-69788", "case_name": "ROSELTRANS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-90214", "case_name": "STANKOVSKAYA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-195196", "case_name": "JKP VODOVOD KRALJEVO v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "002-1353", "case_name": "MANOLE ET AUTRES c. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-181123", "case_name": "Yuriy Valentinovich SHIKUNOV against Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-174860", "case_name": "STOKOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-123144", "case_name": "RADA v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-180841", "case_name": "KEŠELJ AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-161327", "case_name": "STOKOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-226382", "case_name": "KOLOSAY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "002-13063", "case_name": "SLOVENIA v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-80063", "case_name": "GRIGORYEV AND KAKAUROVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-213162", "case_name": "TRANSPETROL, A.S. v. SLOVAKIA", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-77398", "case_name": "TARNAVSKIY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-174679", "case_name": "Aleksandr Vadimovich ABELMAS against Russia and 7 other applications", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "002-10217", "case_name": "Liseytseva et Maslov c. Russie", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-158775", "case_name": "PETROVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-226233", "case_name": "SUKHOY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-126349", "case_name": "MIJANOVIĆ v. MONTENEGRO", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-128012", "case_name": "JKP VODOVOD KRALJEVO against Serbia and JKP VODOVOD KRALJEVO (II) against Serbia", "country": "Serbia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-207002", "case_name": "GÉORGIE c. RUSSIE (I)", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-235282", "case_name": "BULGARIAN NATIONAL RADIO v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-187937", "case_name": "MATVEYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "002-9487", "case_name": "NATSVLISHVILI ET TOGONIDZE c. GÉORGIE", "country": "Georgia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-68842", "case_name": "PIRYANIK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-67328", "case_name": "RADIO FRANCE AND OTHERS v. FRANCE", "country": "France", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-139756", "case_name": "VASVIJA FERIZOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-174822", "case_name": "IGNJATOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-167096", "case_name": "MARTOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-93748", "case_name": "GRIŠEVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-72043", "case_name": "RATNIKOV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-204669", "case_name": "CHYPRE c. TURQUIE", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2001}, {"doc_id": "001-28954", "case_name": "RENFE v. SPAIN", "country": "Spain", "year": 1997}, {"doc_id": "001-157169", "case_name": "VACHEV v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-172263", "case_name": "VOLKOV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-157568", "case_name": "UKRAINE v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-156659", "case_name": "Andris JAUNZEMS and others v. Latvia", "country": "Latvia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-125655", "case_name": "COMINGERSOLL S. A. v. PORTUGAL", "country": "Portugal", "year": 2000}, {"doc_id": "001-146774", "case_name": "LISEYTSEVA AND MASLOV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-120753", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-81539", "case_name": "Brumărescu and 30 other cases against Romania", "country": "Romania", "year": 1999}, {"doc_id": "001-83951", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-142897", "case_name": "GLIGORIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-78404", "case_name": "VILIKANOV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-107743", "case_name": "TRANSPETROL, a.s. v. SLOVAKIA", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-172181", "case_name": "KYPR PROTI TURECKU", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2001}, {"doc_id": "001-143029", "case_name": "ZARKOV v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-146746", "case_name": "BALENOVIĆ v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-118947", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-125606", "case_name": "SHARENOK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-221471", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM (No. 2)", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2022}, {"doc_id": "001-158689", "case_name": "LUČIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-70365", "case_name": "CHERNOBRYVKO v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-182070", "case_name": "Fedor Alekseyevich KIRSANOV and Others v. Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "002-320", "case_name": "TRANSPETROL, A.S. v. SLOVAKIA", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-76682", "case_name": "YANAKIEV v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-119398", "case_name": "COMPAGNIE DE NAVIGATION DE LA RÉPUBLIQUE ISLAMIQUE D'IRAN v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-23970", "case_name": "ROSELTRANS, FINLEASE and Boris Vladimirovich MYSHKIN v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-154983", "case_name": "LJUBLJANSKA BANKA D.D. against Croatia", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-79125", "case_name": "KHURKUNOV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-247727", "case_name": "MANOLE ET AUTRES", "country": "Republic of Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-231336", "case_name": "BOŠKOĆEVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-165736", "case_name": "SOKOLOV AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-233794", "case_name": "BOŽOVIĆ I DRUGI protiv CRNE GORE", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-125610", "case_name": "DERKACH AND PALEK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-79303", "case_name": "SHLEPKIN v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-119268", "case_name": "ZASTAVA IT TURS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-67581", "case_name": "MIKHAÏLENKI AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-194295", "case_name": "YORDANOVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2019}, {"doc_id": "001-117828", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-118629", "case_name": "СУДНОХІДНА КОМПАНІЯ ІСЛАМСЬКОЇ РЕСПУБЛІКИ ІРАН (ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES) ПРОТИ ТУРЕЧЧИНИ", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-200837", "case_name": "SHMATOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-196677", "case_name": "KUZHELEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2019}, {"doc_id": "001-73023", "case_name": "LISYANSKIY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-173262", "case_name": "MENSHIKOV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-186150", "case_name": "CHIM AND PRZYWIECZERSKI v. POLAND", "country": "Poland", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-163800", "case_name": "KALUGINA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-174857", "case_name": "BUGARIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-142930", "case_name": "R. KAČAPOR AND OTHER APPLICANTS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-100212", "case_name": "LIETUVOS NACIONALINIS RADIJAS IR TELEVIZIJA AND TAPINAS IR PARTNERIAI v. LITHUANIA", "country": "Lithuania", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-123150", "case_name": "CONE v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-223302", "case_name": "CROATIAN RADIO-TELEVISION v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2023}, {"doc_id": "001-93896", "case_name": "PROKOPYEVA c. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-108879", "case_name": "RADOMIR ANDRIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-185599", "case_name": "YORDANOVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-166916", "case_name": "RUBIN AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-230162", "case_name": "MEHMEDOVIĆ ET AUTRES, DENĆAN ET AUTRES, VELIČKOVIĆ ET AUTRES, BAKIĆ ET BOJIČIĆ", "country": "Serbia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-22846", "case_name": "FORTUM OIL AND GAS OY v. FINLAND", "country": "Finland", "year": 2002}, {"doc_id": "001-104147", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM", "country": "Belgium", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-98130", "case_name": "YERSHOVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-165398", "case_name": "Aleksandr Yevgenyevich ZHDANOV against Russia and 15 other applications", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-174855", "case_name": "BLAGOJEVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-184981", "case_name": "LIBERT v. FRANCE", "country": "France", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-165712", "case_name": "NATSVLISHVILI AND TOGONIDZE v. GEORGIA", "country": "Georgia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-214820", "case_name": "17 cases against the Russian Federation", "country": "Russian Federation", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-50679", "case_name": "GREECE AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM", "country": "United Kingdom", "year": 1997}, {"doc_id": "002-2085", "case_name": "Cone v. Romania", "country": "Romania", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-101215", "case_name": "SLOVENSKÉ TELEKOMUNIKÁCIE, Š.P. AND HEROLD TELE MEDIA, S.R.O. v. SLOVAKIA", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-109537", "case_name": "RADMILO TOMIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-140928", "case_name": "PETROVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-159666", "case_name": "NAK NAFTOGAZ UKRAINY v. THE UNITED KINGDOM", "country": "United Kingdom", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-162951", "case_name": "JÓZSEF HOLLÓ v. HUNGARY", "country": "Hungary", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "002-10148", "case_name": "Liseytseva and Maslov v. Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-245065", "case_name": "OCUL AND OTHERS v. THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2025}, {"doc_id": "001-96149", "case_name": "KASYANCHUK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-112709", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-185608", "case_name": "MYKHAYLENKY AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-180837", "case_name": "TYUTINA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-122216", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-244092", "case_name": "BEŠOVIĆ ET AUTRES, ADROVIĆ ET AUTRES, BOŽOVIĆ ET AUTRES, BOLJEVIĆ ET AUTRES, ABDOVIĆ ET AUTRES, ŽIVALJEVIĆ ET AUTRES", "country": "Montenegro", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-158699", "case_name": "JOVANOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-209806", "case_name": "ROMAN OLEKSIYOVYCH DOVGYY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-83952", "case_name": "COMPAGNIE DE NAVIGATION DE LA RÉPUBLIQUE ISLAMIQUE D'IRAN v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-68886", "case_name": "SOKUR v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-172296", "case_name": "Vladimir Petrovich VASILYEV against Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-171086", "case_name": "NIKITIN v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-71499", "case_name": "KOSAREVSKAYA ET AUTRES c. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "002-4959", "case_name": "COMPAGNIE DE NAVIGATION DE LA REPUBLIQUE ISLAMIQUE D'IRAN c. TURQUIE", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "001-224864", "case_name": "STEAG GMBH v. GERMANY", "country": "Germany", "year": 2023}, {"doc_id": "001-78595", "case_name": "SOLOVYEV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-173322", "case_name": "Viktor Ivanovich KUZHELEV against Russia and 3 other applications", "country": "Russia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-87755", "case_name": "RENFE (Red Nacional de los Ferrocarriles Españoles) v. SPAIN", "country": "Spain", "year": 1997}, {"doc_id": "001-225072", "case_name": "MASTILOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2022}, {"doc_id": "001-119548", "case_name": "COMPANIA DE NAVIGAȚIE A REPUBLICII ISLAMICE IRAN C. TURCEI", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-88474", "case_name": "SHAFRANOV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-174888", "case_name": "RADOLJUB MARINKOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-102986", "case_name": "KOSKINAS v. GREECE", "country": "Greece", "year": 2002}, {"doc_id": "001-109830", "case_name": "MOJSILOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "002-2336", "case_name": "COMPAGNIE DE NAVIGATION DE LA RÉPUBLIQUE ISLAMIQUE D'IRAN c. TURQUIE", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-138569", "case_name": "GLIGORIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-226354", "case_name": "PETROVA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-226372", "case_name": "KHURKUNOV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-165344", "case_name": "IVAN ROMANOVICH SIROTENKO AGAINST RUSSIA AND 4 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-154903", "case_name": "BUZADJI v. THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-183764", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "001-87581", "case_name": "LEONTYUK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-199032", "case_name": "MLADENOVIĆ v. SERBIA AND OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2019}, {"doc_id": "001-123520", "case_name": "MOLDOVEANU v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-77869", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-112666", "case_name": "S.A. COMBUSTIBIL SOLID v. REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA", "country": "Republic of Moldova", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-186537", "case_name": "RTBF v. BELGIUM", "country": "Belgium", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-67756", "case_name": "DERKACH AND PALEK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-200466", "case_name": "IANCU v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2020}, {"doc_id": "001-153466", "case_name": "NATSVLISHVILI AND TOGONIDZE v. GEORGIA", "country": "Georgia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-180308", "case_name": "Bahrija MUMINOVIĆ against Bosnia and Herzegovina and 3 other applications", "country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-191642", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-100230", "case_name": "SHLEPKIN v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-156561", "case_name": "SPOMENKA STEFANOVIĆ AND ALEKSANDAR STOJANOVIĆ AGAINST SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-174839", "case_name": "VUKOSAVLJEVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-117909", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-195189", "case_name": "KNEŽEVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-108329", "case_name": "Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines against Turkey", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-153567", "case_name": "NATSVLISHVILI AND TOGONIDZE v. GEORGIA", "country": "Georgia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-78958", "case_name": "KOLOSAY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-144590", "case_name": "KOSTIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-180245", "case_name": "BILIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-173321", "case_name": "KUDRYASHOVA AND TOMILIN v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-96842", "case_name": "AURELIA POPA v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-125602", "case_name": "CHERNYAYEV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-195155", "case_name": "MUMINOVIĆ v. BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA AND OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Bosnia and Herzegovina", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-78962", "case_name": "PETROVA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-158800", "case_name": "RADOVANOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-83838", "case_name": "ALEKSANDROVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-174615", "case_name": "KRNDIJA AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-173100", "case_name": "IGNJATOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-99901", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2010}, {"doc_id": "001-242621", "case_name": "IVANOVA AND VASILEV v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2025}, {"doc_id": "001-220575", "case_name": "GÉORGIE c. RUSSIE (I)", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-235372", "case_name": "BEŞLEAGĂ AND OTHERS", "country": "Romania", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-23161", "case_name": "THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "002-4958", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "001-117518", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-156499", "case_name": "VORONKOV v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-91748", "case_name": "OTYCHENKO AND FEDISHCHENKO v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-142340", "case_name": "DŽEMAIL JAŠAREVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-87948", "case_name": "MOLDOVEANU c. ROUMANIE", "country": "Romania", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-171385", "case_name": "UJ v. HUNGARY", "country": "Hungary", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-171868", "case_name": "BALANDINA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-187909", "case_name": "JKP VODOVOD KRALJEVO v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-167786", "case_name": "BOGDANOVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-90585", "case_name": "CRNIŠANIN AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-233658", "case_name": "CROATIAN RADIO-TELEVISION v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2023}, {"doc_id": "001-71479", "case_name": "KOPCHINSKIY v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-174846", "case_name": "ŠERIFOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-192471", "case_name": "BASENKO v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-215547", "case_name": "KHACHATRYAN v. ARMENIA", "country": "Armenia", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-116107", "case_name": "DRAGOLJUB ANDRIĆ AGAINST SERBIA AND 23 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-174871", "case_name": "ALEKSANDAR SOKOLOV AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-171509", "case_name": "Yuriy Pavlovich SOROKIN against Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-113301", "case_name": "ADAMOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2012}, {"doc_id": "001-79158", "case_name": "SILKA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-71611", "case_name": "MIROSHNICHENKO AND GRABOVSKAYA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-215709", "case_name": "MASTILOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2022}, {"doc_id": "001-145704", "case_name": "RADOVANOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-233793", "case_name": "BOLJEVIĆ AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO", "country": "Montenegro", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-125396", "case_name": "Mykhaylenky and others v. Ukraine", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2004}, {"doc_id": "001-226160", "case_name": "CROATIAN RADIO-TELEVISION v. CROATIA", "country": "Croatia", "year": 2023}, {"doc_id": "001-243409", "case_name": "BOŠKOĆEVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2024}, {"doc_id": "001-123993", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-172068", "case_name": "KARPESH v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-71186", "case_name": "S.A. COMBUSTIBIL SOLID v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-71623", "case_name": "SOLOVYEVA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "002-319", "case_name": "Transpetrol, a.s., v. Slovakia", "country": "Slovakia", "year": 2011}, {"doc_id": "001-147336", "case_name": "Mikhail Vitalevich Samsonov v. Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-235844", "case_name": "OTYCHENKO AND FEDISHCHENKO v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "002-9346", "case_name": "SOKOLOV ET AUTRES c. SERBIE", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-143019", "case_name": "STOŠIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-121905", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-87106", "case_name": "CONE v. ROMANIA", "country": "Romania", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-91343", "case_name": "STATE HOLDING COMPANY LUGANSKVUGILLYA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-195293", "case_name": "CASE OF GEORGIA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2019}, {"doc_id": "001-227890", "case_name": "GOROBETS v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-162021", "case_name": "STARTSEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-117353", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-170639", "case_name": "POPOVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-78387", "case_name": "SPAS AND VOYNA v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-174872", "case_name": "VASVIJA FERIZOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2013}, {"doc_id": "001-139048", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-216516", "case_name": "COMPAGNIE NATIONALE DE PRODUCTION D’ÉNERGIE NUCLÉAIRE « ENERGOATOM » contre la République de Moldova", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2022}, {"doc_id": "001-68368", "case_name": "SHARENOK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2005}, {"doc_id": "001-80299", "case_name": "STRATEYCHUK v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-140947", "case_name": "ALEKSANDAR SOKOLOV AGAINST SERBIA AND 6 OTHER APPLICATIONS", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "001-112745", "case_name": "MILAN IGNJATOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-23276", "case_name": "VACHEV v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "001-164912", "case_name": "YUDIN AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-181654", "case_name": "Libert v. Franța", "country": "France", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-213710", "case_name": "CERNICA AND NARTEA v. REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA", "country": "Republic of Moldova", "year": 2021}, {"doc_id": "001-235428", "case_name": "S. GMBH v. GERMANY", "country": "Germany", "year": 2023}, {"doc_id": "001-188482", "case_name": "ALEKSANDR GENNADYEVICH MARCHENKO against Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2018}, {"doc_id": "001-180246", "case_name": "RADULOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-170134", "case_name": "KIM AND RYNDINA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-228256", "case_name": "Basyuk v. Ukraine", "country": "Ukraine", "year": null}, {"doc_id": "001-158694", "case_name": "JOVIČIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2015}, {"doc_id": "001-179303", "case_name": "OGUREYEV AND MAKHANOVA v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-174826", "case_name": "ŽIVKOVIĆ v. SERBIA", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "002-9285", "case_name": "Sokolov and Others v. Serbia", "country": "Serbia", "year": 2014}, {"doc_id": "002-2335", "case_name": "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN SHIPPING LINES v. TURKEY", "country": "Turkey", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-80295", "case_name": "GIRYA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2007}, {"doc_id": "001-86251", "case_name": "CHECHIN v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2008}, {"doc_id": "001-168796", "case_name": "Dmitriy Eduardovich KUZNETSOV against Russia and Galina Fedorovna GORBACHEVA against Russia", "country": "Russia", "year": 2016}, {"doc_id": "001-44448", "case_name": "RADIO FRANCE ET AUTRES c. FRANCE", "country": "France", "year": 2003}, {"doc_id": "002-1352", "case_name": "MANOLE AND OTHERS v. MOLDOVA", "country": "Moldova", "year": 2009}, {"doc_id": "001-30429", "case_name": "VELHO DA COSTA DE ABREU ROCHA AND TITO DE MORAIS v. PORTUGAL", "country": "Portugal", "year": 1999}, {"doc_id": "002-11511", "case_name": "KARACHALIOS v. GREECE", "country": "Greece", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-226238", "case_name": "SOLOVYEV v. UKRAINE", "country": "Ukraine", "year": 2006}, {"doc_id": "001-204434", "case_name": "YORDANOVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA", "country": "Bulgaria", "year": 2019}, {"doc_id": "001-179410", "case_name": "INDERKINY v. RUSSIA", "country": "Russia", "year": 2017}, {"doc_id": "001-188321", "case_name": "DIMITRIOS KARACHALIOS v. GREECE", "country": "Greece", "year": 2017}], "shareholder_stats": {"allowed": 423, "denied": 531, "unresolved": 542}, "top_compensation": [{"doc_id": "001-145730", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866404634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-235565", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866404634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-205910", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866404634.0, "year": 2011, "country": "Russian Federation"}, {"doc_id": "001-205909", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866404634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-9971", "case_name": "OAO Neftyanaya Kompaniya Yukos c. Russie", "total_eur": 1866104634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-169161", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866104634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-9746", "case_name": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "total_eur": 1866104634.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-14523", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (IV)", "total_eur": 253038000.0, "year": 2025, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-245255", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (IV)", "total_eur": 253018000.0, "year": 2025, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-14524", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (IV)", "total_eur": 252990000.0, "year": 2025, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-229875", "case_name": "GÉORGIE c. RUSSIE (II)", "total_eur": 133358630.15, "year": 2021, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-229874", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (II)", "total_eur": 133358630.15, "year": 2021, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-14058", "case_name": "Georgia v. Russia (II) (just satisfaction)", "total_eur": 130027500.0, "year": 2023, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "002-14059", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (II) (JUST SATISFACTION)", "total_eur": 129827500.0, "year": 2023, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-224631", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (II)", "total_eur": 129827500.0, "year": 2023, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-224629", "case_name": "GEORGIA v. RUSSIA (II)", "total_eur": 129827500.0, "year": 2023, "country": "Russia"}, {"doc_id": "001-149094", "case_name": "CYPRUS v. TURKEY", "total_eur": 90000000.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Turkey"}, {"doc_id": "001-150957", "case_name": "CYPRUS v. TURKEY", "total_eur": 90000000.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Turkey"}, {"doc_id": "001-144151", "case_name": "CYPRUS v. TURKEY", "total_eur": 90000000.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Turkey"}, {"doc_id": "001-150941", "case_name": "CYPRUS v. TURKEY", "total_eur": 90000000.0, "year": 2014, "country": "Turkey"}], "insights": [{"title": "Shareholder standing", "question": "Can a shareholder complain for the company?", "pct": 0.44339622641509435, "numerator": 423, "denominator": 954, "note": "423 allowed / 531 denied (+542 unresolved)", "link": "/legal-entities", "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Usually only the company itself can bring a Convention claim. In rare circumstances a shareholder (often the sole owner) is let in as a stand-in. This is the Court's acceptance rate when such a claim is actually made."}, {"title": "Legal-entity win rate", "question": "Do companies/NGOs win at the Court?", "pct": 0.4440872239306682, "numerator": 3177, "denominator": 7154, "note": "3,177 of 7,154 cases with ≥1 violation", "link": "/legal-entities", "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Share of legal-entity cases where the Court found at least one violation. High numbers look impressive but count any violation on any article, not full victory."}, {"title": "Natural person win rate", "question": "For comparison — humans winning.", "pct": 0.47956288370962785, "numerator": 67099, "denominator": 139917, "note": "67,099 of 139,917 cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Same metric for individuals. Use it to sanity-check whether the Court is friendlier to people or to entities."}, {"title": "NGO win rate", "question": "Do NGOs fare better than companies?", "pct": 0.6172839506172839, "numerator": 350, "denominator": 567, "note": "350 of 567 NGO cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "NGOs often litigate free-expression, assembly, religion. They tend to have better success than ordinary commercial entities — this is the raw number."}, {"title": "State-owned enterprises", "question": "Can a state company sue its own state in Strasbourg?", "pct": 0.6714801444043321, "numerator": 186, "denominator": 277, "note": "297 SOE cases flagged; 186 with violation", "link": "/legal-entities", "kind": "pct", "explanation": "SOEs raise the question: is a company an independent legal person or an organ of the state? The Court's answer is case-by-case. Here are the flagged SOE cases and how many of them resulted in a violation finding."}, {"title": "P1-1 (property)", "question": "Violation rate on the property article for legal entities.", "pct": 0.3311933534743202, "numerator": 877, "denominator": 2648, "note": "877 / 2,648 legal-entity P1-1 claims", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Article 1 of Protocol 1 — peaceful enjoyment of possessions — is the workhorse article for companies. This is their success rate on it."}, {"title": "Article 6 (fair trial)", "question": "Violation rate on fair-trial claims by legal entities.", "pct": 0.1708185053380783, "numerator": 144, "denominator": 843, "note": "144 / 843 legal-entity Art. 6 claims", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Fair-trial guarantees apply to companies in civil and criminal proceedings. Think: reasonable length, equality of arms, access to court."}, {"title": "Article 10 (expression)", "question": "Legal-entity speech cases — violation rate.", "pct": 0.4280868385345997, "numerator": 631, "denominator": 1474, "note": "631 / 1,474 legal-entity Art. 10 claims", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Freedom of expression claims by non-human applicants — usually publishers, broadcasters, online platforms."}, {"title": "Media under Art. 10", "question": "Do media companies win their free-speech cases?", "pct": 0.6680161943319838, "numerator": 330, "denominator": 494, "note": "330 / 494 media Art. 10 rulings", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Filtered to applicants whose entity subtype is 'media'. High violation rate here is the Court defending press freedom against domestic restrictions."}, {"title": "Religious bodies under Art. 9", "question": "Violation rate on freedom-of-religion claims.", "pct": 0.43982494529540483, "numerator": 201, "denominator": 457, "note": "201 / 457 religious Art. 9 rulings", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Churches, parishes, religious associations claiming under Article 9. Registration refusals and property disputes dominate this strand."}, {"title": "Trade unions under Art. 11", "question": "Union wins on freedom of association.", "pct": 0.38028169014084506, "numerator": 135, "denominator": 355, "note": "135 / 355 trade-union Art. 11 rulings", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Union-specific Article 11 rulings. Covers recognition, collective bargaining, and the right to strike as shaped by Demir/Baykara line."}, {"title": "Political parties under Art. 11", "question": "Do parties prevail in Strasbourg?", "pct": 0.4098939929328622, "numerator": 116, "denominator": 283, "note": "116 / 283 party Art. 11 rulings", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Dissolution or refusal of registration of political parties — one of the most politically sensitive strands of the Court's case law."}, {"title": "Energy sector", "question": "YUKOS is not alone — violation rate for energy applicants.", "pct": 0.4465753424657534, "numerator": 163, "denominator": 365, "note": "163 / 365 energy-sector cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Oil, gas, power: applicants whose industry was tagged 'energy'. Often intersecting with state expropriation and tax disputes."}, {"title": "Category A (direct)", "question": "Legal entities bringing their own case — violation rate.", "pct": null, "numerator": 0, "denominator": 0, "note": "0 / 0 direct-applicant cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Our taxonomy: A = the company / NGO files the application itself. This is the cleanest slice for studying corporate human-rights law."}, {"title": "Category B (shareholder proxy)", "question": "Cases where a shareholder stands in for a company.", "pct": null, "numerator": 0, "denominator": 0, "note": "0 / 0 shareholder-proxy cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "B cases are the doctrinal puzzle — an individual complains about harm actually done to the company. See Agrotexim and its progeny."}, {"title": "Russia vs legal entities", "question": "Violation rate in legal-entity cases v. Russia.", "pct": 0.5478723404255319, "numerator": 103, "denominator": 188, "note": "251 legal-entity cases, 103 with violation", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Russia was expelled from the Council in 2022 but remains respondent in earlier filings. High violation rate reflects a confrontational record."}, {"title": "Turkey vs legal entities", "question": "Violation rate in legal-entity cases v. Turkey.", "pct": 0.49646643109540634, "numerator": 281, "denominator": 566, "note": "693 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Turkey is consistently one of the largest respondents overall; this is its specific record against non-human applicants."}, {"title": "Companies (corporate) win rate", "question": "Only applicants tagged as commercial companies.", "pct": 0.4630902570233114, "numerator": 3099, "denominator": 6692, "note": "3,099 / 6,692 company cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Narrower than 'legal entity' — excludes NGOs, unions, churches, media. The slice most relevant to business-human-rights literature."}, {"title": "Friendly settlements", "question": "How often legal entities settle before a ruling.", "pct": 0.05339670114621191, "numerator": 382, "denominator": 7154, "note": "382 settled / 7154 legal-entity outcomes", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Friendly settlement closes the case without a merits judgment. Not really a 'win' in doctrinal terms — often used when facts are embarrassing for the state."}, {"title": "Inadmissibility trap", "question": "Share of legal-entity claims thrown out as inadmissible.", "pct": 0.38146491473301647, "numerator": 2729, "denominator": 7154, "note": "2,729 inadmissible / 7,154", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Inadmissibility (ratione personae, materiae, six-month rule, non-exhaustion…) is how the Court disposes of the bulk of its docket. Watch this ratio — it is a better gauge of procedural hurdles than win rate."}, {"title": "Struck-out cases", "question": "Legal-entity cases removed from the list.", "pct": 0.06905227844562482, "numerator": 494, "denominator": 7154, "note": "494 struck out / 7154", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Cases withdrawn, abandoned, or resolved domestically. Does not mean the applicant lost — just that the Court stepped back."}, {"title": "Satisfaction denied", "question": "Court finds a violation but awards nothing.", "pct": 0.061061226741700114, "numerator": 4427, "denominator": 72501, "note": "4,427 of 72,501 cases with a violation", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Sometimes the Court holds that 'the finding of a violation is in itself sufficient just satisfaction'. Denominator is cases that actually had a violation, so the ratio answers: of the wins, how many walked away empty-handed?"}, {"title": "Grand Chamber escalation", "question": "Share of legal-entity cases heard by the Grand Chamber.", "pct": 0.046887725421756836, "numerator": 403, "denominator": 8595, "note": "403 of 8,595 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Grand Chamber hears cases of doctrinal importance. A high escalation rate for legal entities suggests the Court keeps finding new questions in this strand."}, {"title": "Post-2015 surge", "question": "Legal-entity cases judged since 2015.", "pct": 0.2916812100058173, "numerator": 2507, "denominator": 8595, "note": "2,507 of 8,595 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Share of legal-entity rulings issued in the last decade. A quick proxy for whether the corporate strand is growing or stagnating."}, {"title": "Average award to companies", "question": "Mean just-satisfaction when a legal entity is paid.", "value": 6921134.797918367, "numerator": 1960, "denominator": null, "note": "mean across 1,960 paid legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "eur", "explanation": "Arithmetic mean — dragged up massively by Yukos. Look at the median card next to it, and the log-scale scatter on the Compensation page, to see the real distribution."}, {"title": "Median award to companies", "question": "The honest middle — half get less, half get more.", "value": 7600.0, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "median across 1,960 paid legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "eur", "explanation": "Median strips out the Yukos-style outliers. This is a truer picture of what a successful corporate applicant actually walks away with."}, {"title": "Largest award to a company", "question": "Biggest single payout to a legal entity.", "value": 1866404634.0, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "link": "/case/001-145730", "kind": "eur", "explanation": "Top of the distribution for non-human applicants. Useful as a reference point when thinking about what 'serious money' looks like in Strasbourg."}, {"title": "Total € to legal entities", "question": "Sum of all just-satisfaction ever ordered for legal entities.", "value": 13565424203.92, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "across 8,595 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "eur", "explanation": "Aggregate money the Court has ordered states to pay out to non-human applicants across the whole corpus."}, {"title": "Largest single award", "question": "The Yukos outlier.", "value": 1866404634.0, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "OAO NEFTYANAYA KOMPANIYA YUKOS v. RUSSIA", "link": "/case/001-145730", "kind": "eur", "explanation": "The €1.87 billion Yukos pecuniary award is the largest in the Court's history by orders of magnitude. Click through for the full record."}, {"title": "Individual award (avg)", "question": "Average to a natural person (for comparison).", "value": 38891.98321004949, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "mean across paid natural-person cases", "link": null, "kind": "eur", "explanation": "Reference point for the 'average award to companies' card. Individuals typically receive a fraction of what companies do."}, {"title": "First legal-entity case", "question": "Earliest ECHR ruling involving a legal entity.", "value": 1964, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "dataset-wide scan", "link": null, "kind": "year", "explanation": "The year of the first legal-entity judgment we can find. Gives a rough sense of when the Court started treating companies as full rights-holders."}, {"title": "High-confidence share", "question": "Extractions the model flagged as 'high' confidence.", "pct": 0.8789372683959767, "numerator": 159390, "denominator": 181344, "note": "159,390 of 181,344", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "DeepSeek self-reports a confidence field on every extraction. Only 'high' is counted here. Treat low-confidence rows as hints, not citations."}, {"title": "Grand Chamber violation rate", "question": "When the big bench speaks, does it find the state in the wrong?", "pct": 0.35768261964735515, "numerator": 142, "denominator": 397, "note": "142 / 397 GC legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Grand Chamber cases are pre-selected for doctrinal weight. A high violation rate here means the Court is using its biggest formation to side with legal entities."}, {"title": "Committee-formation share", "question": "Mass-production rulings by 3-judge committees.", "pct": 0.14845840605002908, "numerator": 1276, "denominator": 8595, "note": "1,276 of 8,595 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Committees handle repetitive, well-established violations. A high share here signals routine, chamber-of-commerce-style litigation rather than novel doctrine."}, {"title": "Articles per legal-entity case", "question": "On average, how many Convention provisions one case raises.", "value": 1.72, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "mean across 8,595 legal-entity cases", "link": null, "kind": "count", "explanation": "Legal-entity cases often stack claims (P1-1 + Art. 6, for instance). This average gives you a feel for case complexity."}, {"title": "Costs-only awards", "question": "Cases where the Court awarded only procedural costs, nothing else.", "pct": 0.02447833950944062, "numerator": 4439, "denominator": 181344, "note": "4,439 of 181,344 cases overall", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Applicant recovers lawyer's fees but no pecuniary or non-pecuniary damages. Usually means the violation was symbolic or the harm unquantifiable."}, {"title": "Non-pecuniary to companies", "question": "Does the Court award moral damages to a corporation?", "pct": 0.15009174311926604, "numerator": 1227, "denominator": 8175, "note": "1,227 of 8,175 company-subtype cases", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "A long doctrinal debate: can a legal person have a 'reputation' that suffers? Comingersoll v. Portugal said yes. This card shows how often it happens in practice."}, {"title": "Most legal-entity-friendly jurisdiction", "question": "Country with the highest share of cases brought by legal entities.", "value": 0, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "Moldova — 15.2% (2,126 total)", "link": null, "kind": "count", "explanation": "Among states with at least 300 filings, which has the highest share of legal-entity applicants? Can hint at where corporate ECHR litigation is most active."}, {"title": "Most invoked article", "question": "The provision cited most often across the whole corpus.", "value": 77727, "numerator": 0, "denominator": null, "note": "Article 6-1 — 77,727 invocations", "link": null, "kind": "count", "explanation": "Not violation rate — just pure invocation count. Gives a sense of which article is the Court's workhorse."}, {"title": "Research-relevant share", "question": "How much of the corpus is actually about legal entities?", "pct": 0.09627007234868537, "numerator": 17458, "denominator": 181344, "note": "17,458 flagged relevant of 181,344", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Categories A + B versus everything else. If you wonder how big our study universe actually is, this is the answer."}, {"title": "B-shareholder acceptance", "question": "When a shareholder stands in, what fraction are let through?", "pct": 0.2827540106951872, "numerator": 423, "denominator": 1496, "note": "423 allowed / 1496 total B-claims", "link": null, "kind": "pct", "explanation": "Stricter denominator than the 'Shareholder standing' card — includes unresolved. This is the true base rate if you were filing such a claim tomorrow."}]}